Skip to content
No pain relief? Full money back! 60-Day Guarantee

Quick question before you join

How are you doing with your sciatica right now?

Skip
CommunityBridge Want to create your own forum? Click here
Julie
Julie's Sciatica Support Group
Public group Β· 4,812 members
Julie

Julie's Sciatica Support Group

A place to share what works, what doesn't, and everything in between
Hi everyone, I'm Julie. Mom of 3, been dealing with sciatica for about 3 years now. I've tried physio, chiro, painkillers, heating pads, TENS machines, and probably over $2,000 worth of stuff I found online. Nothing has made a real difference. Started this group because I was tired of being sold things everywhere I looked. No ads here, no products I'm pushing. Just people trying to figure this out together. If something helped you even a little please share it. And if you just need to vent that's fine too.
Members: 4,812Posts: 2,341Last post: 2 min agoOnline now: 47

Main thread: What has actually helped your sciatica?

Newest replies first Β· 240 comments
M
Margaret T.
6 min ago
Still struggling
just found this group. been at this 3 years and still no real answers. glad this place exists at least.
Reply
R
Ronald G.
9 min ago
Still struggling
week 3. still awful.
Reply
E
Edith C.
12 min ago
Still struggling
does anyone else feel like giving up on doctors entirely
Reply
M
Mona T.
10 min ago
Still struggling
@Edith yes. frequently.
Reply
S
Sandra K.
22 min ago
Recovered
@Rose went to a physio who actually knew about the piriformis after reading your comment. doing a lot better now. thanks for posting that.
Reply
N
Norma P.
18 min ago
Still struggling
@Sandra which comment? I'm new here, trying to find it.
Reply
P
Patricia O.
29 min ago
Still struggling
helpppp
Reply
J
Janet M.
27 min ago
Still struggling
@Patricia what's going on?
Reply
P
Patricia O.
25 min ago
Still struggling
@Janet I'm really suffering. can't sit, can't stand, can't sleep. been 6 months of this.
Reply
Load 1 more reply
W
Walter S.
33 min ago
Still struggling
day 4 of not being able to put on my own socks.
Reply
D
Dennis B.
41 min ago
Still struggling
tried acupuncture for 3 months. $1,800 out of pocket. didn't do much. I'm 63 and I never thought I'd spend my retirement dealing with this.
Reply
G
Gerald P.
35 min ago
Still struggling
@Dennis I did acupuncture too. maybe 10% relief. not worth the cost long term in my opinion.
Reply
N
Nancy P.
1h ago
Still struggling
woke up in pain again this morning. it's been every single day for over a year. my husband doesn't really get it. hard to explain what it's like when it never stops.
Reply
J
Joyce M.
58 min ago
Still struggling
@Nancy my husband is the same. "have you tried ibuprofen?" yes, I've tried ibuprofen.
Reply
E
Evelyn R.
50 min ago
Recovered
@Nancy hang in there. it does get better for some people. keep looking.
Reply
Load 1 more reply
L
Linda H.
2h ago
Still struggling
does anyone get the burning that goes all the way down to the foot? not just pain, more like heat under the skin. been 8 months. MRI showed a bulging disc at L4-L5 but surgeon said not bad enough for surgery. so I'm just here.
Reply
S
Sandra W.
1h ago
Still struggling
@Linda yes, the burning is different from regular pain. hard to describe to people who haven't had it.
Reply
K
Karen M.
1h ago
Still struggling
@Linda right leg only, started after a long car trip about two years ago. same here.
Reply
Load 1 more reply
C
Carol P.
2h ago
Still struggling
kind of embarrassing that I had to find out about the piriformis from a forum and not from any of the 4 doctors I've seen. @Rose thanks for sharing what your sister told you.
Reply
D
Donna W.
2h ago
Still struggling
@Carol same. I pay these people a lot and I learn more from here in a week than from months of appointments.
Reply
C
Carol J.
3h ago
Recovered
heat packs in the morning help me get through the first couple hours. not fixing anything but makes it more manageable. anyone find heat works better than ice?
Reply
B
Barbara N.
3h ago
Still struggling
@Carol heat yes. ice makes mine worse. my physio said to use ice and it was wrong for me.
Reply
F
Frank D.
3h ago
Still struggling
@Carol heat helps for about an hour then it's back. but I'll take that hour.
Reply
Load 1 more reply
K
Kenneth W.
4h ago
Still struggling
cortisone injection helped for about 6 weeks then came right back. doctor says max 3 a year so I'm rationing them. not really a solution.
Reply
P
Phyllis R.
3h ago
Still struggling
@Kenneth same. 6 weeks of relief then back to square one. I'm on my second of three for the year.
Reply
Julie
Julie
5h ago
Group Admin
when I started this group I wasn't really expecting to find an answer here. just looking for people who understood what I was going through. but after reading @Rose's comment and doing my own research I've had some actual relief for the first time in 3 years. still not 100% but I finally feel like I understand what's actually been wrong. thanks Rose, and thanks everyone here.
Reply
L
Linda H.
4h ago
Still struggling
@Julie glad to hear it. gives me some hope.
Reply
E
Earl S.
6h ago
Still struggling
been on gabapentin 8 months. takes the edge off maybe 30%. the brain fog is rough and I've put on weight. it's managing the pain but not fixing anything. I'd rather find the actual problem.
Reply
M
Muriel D.
5h ago
Still struggling
@Earl the fog got bad enough that I stopped driving. that was a line for me.
Reply
I
Irene B.
7h ago
Still struggling
every time I see a sciatica product ad on facebook I get annoyed. they all claim 97% success rate in 3 days. I've bought a few over the years. none did what they said.
Reply
H
Herbert A.
6h ago
Still struggling
@Irene tried to get a refund from one of them. took weeks of emails and they gave back about 15% of what I paid.
Reply
V
Vincent R.
10h ago
Recovered
so it's the piriformis. not the disc. been treating the wrong thing for 3 years. read @Rose's comment if you haven't, it's a few days back in the thread.
Reply
M
Margaret C.
9h ago
Still struggling
@Vincent what is piriformis? genuinely never heard of it
Reply
N
Nancy T.
9h ago
Still struggling
@Margaret it's a muscle in the buttock area. can press on the sciatic nerve. look for Rose's comment a few days back, she explains it.
Reply
R
Ronald B.
8h ago
Still struggling
@Vincent I'm a bit skeptical about all these "real cause" theories that keep coming around. herniated disc shows up on MRI, piriformis doesn't. hard to know what to believe.
Reply
Load 2 more replies
T
Thomas C.
11h ago
Still struggling
swimming helps more than anything else I've tried. maybe 20% improvement. but I'm 67 and can't get to the pool every day so it's not really practical long term.
Reply
H
Harold S.
11h ago
Still struggling
@Thomas same with me and walking. helps while I'm doing it. doesn't last.
Reply
B
Beatrice L.
1 day ago
Still struggling
I've been researching this for 2 years and every source contradicts the next one. sleep on your back, no sleep on your side. exercise more, no rest more. stretch, don't stretch. at some point you stop trusting any of it.
Reply
C
Clarence B.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Beatrice the contradictory advice is one of the most frustrating parts honestly.
Reply
L
Lois M.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Beatrice I literally have a list of things I've been told to do that directly contradict each other.
Reply
Load 1 more reply
A
Agnes F.
1 day ago
Still struggling
had to skip my granddaughter's soccer game last weekend. can't stand for that long. it's these small things that add up.
Reply
M
Mabel H.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Agnes yes. it's not even the pain itself most days, it's what you can't do because of it.
Reply
H
Helen V.
1 day ago
Still struggling
my chiropractor mentioned something called piriformis syndrome once and then never brought it up again. I didn't know what it was so I didn't ask. now I kind of wish I had.
Reply
A
Arthur L.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Helen same thing happened to me. mentioned it once and moved on. should have asked.
Reply
N
Norman J.
1 day ago
Still struggling
short walks help a bit. 10-15 minutes max. more than that and I'm paying for it the rest of the day. not a solution but it's something.
Reply
G
Gladys T.
2 days ago
Still struggling
my appointments are 10-15 minutes. not long enough to actually talk through what's happening. I leave with less information than I came in with sometimes.
Reply
E
Ernest G.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Gladys mine spent half the appointment typing with his back to me.
Reply
M
Marilyn G.
2 days ago
Still struggling
I've spent a lot of money on this. physio, chiro, massage, two MRIs, three doctors, spinal decompression, supplements, a special mattress, four different cushions. still in the same place as a year ago.
Reply
R
Ruth A.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Marilyn the cushion rabbit hole is real. I think I have five now. none of them work.
Reply
R
Raymond T.
2 days ago
Still struggling
physio helped maybe 30%. the stretches did take the edge off. but my physio never explained why those specific stretches help. just handed me a sheet. after reading @Rose's comment about the piriformis I'm wondering if that's actually what those stretches were targeting all along.
Reply
G
Geraldine W.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Raymond nobody explains the mechanics. just "do these exercises." frustrating.
Reply
D
Dorothy M.
3 days ago
Still struggling
my sister is a doctor and she basically admitted that the medical world doesn't have great answers for sciatica. she said most of what gets prescribed is just managing symptoms. hard to hear but at least explains why nothing has really worked.
Reply
C
Charles F.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Dorothy that tracks. I've had the feeling for a while that they're just guessing along with the rest of us.
Reply
V
Virginia S.
3 days ago
Still struggling
four years of this. seen six different specialists. done everything they've told me. starting to wonder if this is just how things are now.
Reply
J
Julie (admin)
3 days ago
Group Admin
@Virginia please don't stop looking. there are people in this group who turned a corner after years of nothing working.
Reply
M
Mildred C.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Virginia I know that feeling. going on 18 months. some days it's hard not to just accept it.
Reply
Load 1 more reply
L
Leonard T.
4 days ago
Still struggling
want to be honest about what I've spent in the last year. chiropractor $800. two rounds of physio $1,200. inversion table $400. decompression therapy $900. random stuff online probably another $800. specialist co-pays $500. that's over $5,000 and I'm in the same amount of pain. I don't regret trying. but it's a lot of money for nothing to show for it.
ReplyπŸ’¬ 24 replies
J
Janet C.
4 days ago
Still struggling
@Leonard I'd rather not add up what I've spent. it would be depressing.
Reply
G
Glenn B.
4 days ago
Still struggling
@Leonard you're not a fool for trying. when you're in pain you look for anything.
Reply
Load 4 more replies
F
Frances B.
5 days ago
Still struggling
been lurking here for a few weeks. first time posting. this group has been more helpful than most of my medical appointments just in terms of feeling like someone understands what I'm going through.
Reply
M
Morris D.
5 days ago
Still struggling
anyone notice their pain is worse when they're stressed? I've been dealing with some stuff at home and it's been noticeably worse. not sure if that's a coincidence.
Reply
F
Florence K.
5 days ago
Still struggling
@Morris not a coincidence in my case. always worse when stressed or not sleeping well.
Reply
H
Harold K.
6 days ago
Still struggling
TENS machine did nothing for me. everyone online says it works. maybe I used it wrong. $200 gone.
Reply
E
Edith R.
6 days ago
Recovered
@Harold worked for me but only a little. like 10-15% relief and only while it was on. not a fix.
Reply
O
Oscar T.
6 days ago
Still struggling
six years of this. kind of stopped expecting it to go away. just trying to keep it manageable at this point.
Reply
C
Cornelius B.
6 days ago
Still struggling
@Oscar seven years here. 64. I just want to play golf again. one round. that's it.
Reply
A
Arnold M.
7 days ago
Still struggling
my wife thinks I'm exaggerating. she's never had chronic pain so it's hard for her to understand. I don't hold it against her but it does get lonely.
Reply
P
Pauline G.
7 days ago
Still struggling
@Arnold mine said something similar once. it's hard when the people closest to you don't quite get it.
Reply
R
Rufus P.
7 days ago
Still struggling
69 years old. had this since I was 61. kind of assumed it was just part of getting older. reading this group made me think maybe it doesn't have to be permanent.
Reply
M
Myrtle H.
8 days ago
Still struggling
reading back through this thread. a lot of us have had the same experiences, tried the same things, gotten the same non-answers. at least we're not alone in it.
Reply
H
Harold B.
9 days ago
Still struggling
learned more useful things from this group in two weeks than from years of appointments. not sure what that says about the medical system.
Reply
R
Rose W.
3 days ago
Recovered
been reading this thread for a while and finally have something to share that might actually be useful. my sister is an orthopedic surgeon. a few weeks ago she explained something that changed how I've been thinking about my sciatica. she said a lot of cases that get blamed on a herniated disc are actually caused by a muscle called the piriformis. it sits deep in the buttock area and when it gets too tight it can press directly on the sciatic nerve. that's what causes the leg pain, the burning, the numbness going down the leg. the nerve itself is fine. the muscle is compressing it. she said it's more common than doctors tend to check for, partly because standard MRI doesn't show muscle problems clearly. so they see a disc on the scan and focus on that, even when the disc might not actually be the real problem. found this article that goes through it in more detail with diagrams: https://sciaticare.site/pages/article8 not selling anything. just an article. sharing because I wish I'd found this two years ago.
ReplyπŸ’¬ 79 replies
A
Agnes F.
2h ago
Still struggling
@Rose bookmarked this. something to come back to.
Reply
W
Wilbur C.
4h ago
Still struggling
@Rose was about to schedule surgery. reading this first. glad I saw it.
Reply
G
Grace P.
3h ago
Recovered
@Wilbur I almost had surgery too. glad I waited and looked into this first. worth ruling it out before doing anything irreversible.
Reply
M
Minnie T.
9h ago
Still struggling
@Rose went to my physio and mentioned piriformis. she said "let's test for that" and turns out that's exactly what's been going on. only 3 weeks into targeted treatment but something feels different already.
Reply
C
Clifford B.
14h ago
Still struggling
@Rose I mentioned this to my doctor. he said "piriformis syndrome is real but it's often overdiagnosed." I don't know who to believe anymore.
Reply
L
Lorraine T.
19h ago
Still struggling
@Rose showed this to my husband. he asked why my doctors hadn't mentioned it. I said I have no idea.
Reply
H
Harold S.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Rose I've tried to find a physio who takes this seriously. third one I've called. most of them don't seem familiar with it as the primary cause.
Reply
P
Priscilla N.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Rose read the article twice. makes a lot of sense. finally feel like I understand what might actually be going on.
Reply
V
Vera M.
1 day ago
Recovered
@Rose about 70% better after 8 weeks focusing on the piriformis. slept through the night last week for the first time in two years.
Reply
N
Norma H.
1 day ago
Still struggling
@Vera how do you find a physio who knows about this specifically? do you just ask when you call?
Reply
G
Gladys M.
2 days ago
Recovered
@Rose worked specifically on the piriformis β€” targeted stretches, foam rolling, physio who knew what they were looking for. took about 10 weeks to notice a real difference. not fully there yet but functioning again.
Reply
B
Blanche T.
2 days ago
Recovered
@Rose two years ago nothing was working. then I found out about the piriformis and it changed the direction of things. still took time but knowing the actual cause made a real difference.
Reply
K
Karen B.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose brought this to my physio. she said she tests for piriformis routinely and has never found it to be the issue in the patients she sees. now I don't know what to think.
Reply
T
Teresa W.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Dr.MargChen a doctor from Mayo Clinic in this thread. ok. reading that article tonight.
Reply
Dr
Dr. Margaret Chen
2 days ago
Recovered
@Rose I work at Mayo Clinic. a significant portion of the patients we see with a sciatica diagnosis are actually dealing with piriformis compression, not a disc problem. it's undertreated. your post is accurate.
Reply
T
Terry B.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose I brought this up with my doctor. she kind of brushed it off, said "that's quite rare." not sure she's right about that.
Reply
R
Raymond P.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose read the article but not sure this applies to me. my pain is mostly lower back, not really shooting down the leg. could piriformis still be relevant?
Reply
S
Stephanie M.
2 days ago
Recovered
@Rose I'm a nurse. the piriformis issue genuinely doesn't get enough attention in standard medical training. it's a real gap.
Reply
A
Amy L.
2 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose why isn't this talked about more? seems like something that should come up earlier.
Reply
J
Jerome W.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose 4 years of appointments and I find out about this in a facebook group. I'm not blaming the doctors personally but the system definitely dropped the ball here.
Reply
O
Olive M.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose went back through my old physio notes after reading this. there it is: "piriformis tightness noted." nobody said a word to me about what that meant.
Reply
W
Wanda F.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose my herniated disc has been the focus of every appointment for 3 years. hard to imagine that might not even be the real issue. but reading that article it makes sense.
Reply
L
Lloyd C.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose taking this to my doctor next week. what should I specifically ask for?
Reply
B
Bernice A.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose read the article. if this is right I've been going after the wrong thing for two years. bit frustrating but good to finally have a direction.
Reply
R
Rose W.
3 days ago
Recovered
@Keith fair point. I can't say it's everyone's issue. but my sister specifically looked at my symptoms and said it fit. and the article cites actual research. worth at least asking your doctor about it.
Reply
K
Keith M.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose I'm a bit skeptical honestly. I've seen a lot of "real cause" claims over the years. what makes you confident this is actually the issue and not just another theory?
Reply
R
Rose W.
3 days ago
Recovered
@Marjorie @Donald to answer the questions β€” it's a muscle deep in the glute area. when it's too tight it sits right on the sciatic nerve and compresses it. the nerve itself isn't damaged. the article explains it better than I can and has diagrams.
Reply
P
Pearl N.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose read the article. a lot of it matches what I've been experiencing. why has nobody mentioned this to me in three years.
Reply
C
Carl H.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose how do you even pronounce that. dealt with sciatica for 5 years and never heard anyone say this word.
Reply
D
Donald R.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose so the nerve is actually fine and a muscle is causing the problem? is that right?
Reply
M
Marjorie T.
3 days ago
Still struggling
@Rose what is a piriformis? never heard that word before.
Reply
Load 49 more replies
R
Ralph C.
4 days ago
Still struggling
my pain sits around a 6-7 most days. not at the point where I can't function but enough that I think about it constantly. the low-grade constant version is somehow harder than the really bad days.
Reply
N
Norma J.
4 days ago
Still struggling
@Ralph I know exactly what you mean. the constant 6 is somehow harder to accept than the 9s where you just stay in bed.
Reply
G
Gerald S.
5 days ago
Still struggling
had a nerve block done last year. $3,400. helped for maybe 10 days then everything came back. expensive lesson.
Reply
R
Ruth M.
5 days ago
Still struggling
@Gerald 10 days for $3,400. I feel for you.
Reply
O
Oscar R.
6 days ago
Still struggling
been in pain long enough that I honestly can't remember what it felt like before. that might sound dramatic but it's just kind of how it is at this point.
Reply
N
Nancy W.
6 days ago
Still struggling
@Oscar when you have a slightly better day you don't even trust it. you just wait for it to come back.
Reply
M
Maureen S.
8 days ago
Still struggling
been on an MRI waiting list for 6 months. by the time I get it I'll either have figured something out on my own or given up entirely.
Reply
B
Bertha K.
12 days ago
Still struggling
new member. 62 years old. 18 months in with no real answers from four different doctors. found this group last night and read through most of it. first time I've felt like other people actually get it.
Reply
J
Julie (admin)
12 days ago
Group Admin
@Bertha welcome. you're in the right place. keep reading, there's a lot in here that might be useful.
Reply
Julie's Sciatica Support Group is a peer support community. Content shared here reflects personal experience and is not medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional. Created and moderated by Julie M.
Write a reply to the group… Post
Recovered Still struggling